What projects would go into the collections on the front page of the main site?(except the new project and totm collections)
I've always thought that the criteria is "mathy,great and snappy"
But (at least I think) some of my projects have more features than some other projects in the collections(e.g i think my rocket simulator is better than the moon rocket game by @deltav (no offense,im not saying that anyone sucks)) and none of them are in the collections(atleast thats what i see)
Maybe the criteria is "snappiness÷number of blocks" or "code cleaness" or "number of snappidly used sprites" or "<not (on the forum)> and <great?>" or "usefulness for teachers"?
atleast i see most of the projects there have a lot of gui.
I want to know why my projects are bad(if they are)
There's no actual criteria, it's probably just "projects that people with access to the front page collection find interesting"
that being said I don't think you should focus on getting your projects on the front page, you should focus on making them good quality and interesting and it'll probably eventually get there
The Scratch [sic] Team try to pick projects that will inspire users at all skill levels. So one project may be trivial from a programmming standpoint but tell a great story, another might be a great recursively drawn fractal, and yet another might be some great feat of metaprogramming. For us, if the project is basically written in JavaScript, that's a point against it, I guess. So is exceptionally ugly code. But, yeah, each of us picks different kinds of things. I only occasionally feature a project, and essentially never use any of the other categories.